2017 Kirkland Signature ‘California’ Pinot Grigio (1.5L) $7.99
Stephen Lee- The 2017 Kirkland Signature ‘California’ Pinot Grigio underwhelms. This simplistic and unappealing wine shows some ripe apple flavors on the palate. Slightly sweet, this is lacking in complexity. While it’s not flawed wine, it’s pretty blah. Drink 2018-2020, if you really must.- 83
Owen Bargreen- The wine begins with aromas of fruity aromas of pear, kiwi, and melon on the nose. Slightly sweet, this shows good weight on the palate with lighter tree and melon flavors. This impresses for the price. Drink 2018-2020- 86
Scott Doleshel- Here we have an excellent value from Kirkland Signature. It is a touch sweet and cloying but for this price I am impressed. It is a bit out of balance Drink 2018-2022- 87
2016 Kirkland Signature ‘California’ Chardonnay (1.5L) $7.99
Stephen Lee- The label states that the following flavors are present: pineapple, mango, peach, green apple, sweet citrus, oak, honey, and butterscotch. I’m not sure who found any peach in the Chardonnay, because the cloying oak and sweetness hides most of the flavors that the label claims are there. With that in mind, it is still a reasonable value for the bargain price, and will be suitable for hosting large groups and pleasing those who like the “oaky-buttery” style. Drink 2018-2020- 85
Owen Bargreen- Toasty oak marks the nose with butterscotch and roasted pineapple. Slightly sweet, this comes off a bit cloying but delivers vanilla cream and banana flavors with toasted oak flavors that come together in the glass. The mouthfeel is surprisingly impressive. This is a really good value considering the price point for a 1.5L. I can’t imagine the wine improving with age. Drink 2018-2020- 87
Scott Doleshel- This is a tired wine that is out of balance. It is too sweet on the palate with tropical fruits. Drink 2018-2022- 85
2016 Kirkland Signature ‘Sonoma County’ Chardonnay- ($6.99)
Stephen Lee- The 2016 Kirkland Signature ‘California’ Chardonnay is a solid value. Notes of white flowers and apple permeate through on the nose, while the palate is balanced with nice weight. This value-oriented chardonnay offers a leaner, cleaner style than the magnum of California Chardonnay, and many would say it’s better than the more expensive Kirkland Russian River Chardonnay. Drink 2018-2022- 90
Owen Bargreen- Bright citrus tones lead the nose with lighter oak and melon aromatics rounding this Chardonnay out. The wine comes off a touch sweet with brioche, creme brûlée and light melon tones. This is highly simplistic and not recommended. Drink 2018-2022- 87
Scott Doleshel- The ‘Sonoma County’ Chardonnay seems out of balance for me, as it is lightly cloying with tree and citrus fruit flavors. Drink 2018-2022- 87
2015 Kirkland Signature ‘Russian River Valley’ Chardonnay ($12.99)
Stephen Lee- The back of the bottle goes into some appalling over-descriptions of a rather pedestrian wine. They claim this wine offers the following: 1) Lemon blossom 2) Citrus 3) Stone-fruit 4) Delicious 5) Rich 6) Elegant 7) Tightly focused 8) Smoothly textured harmony of fruit 9) Green apple 10) Pear 11) Fig 12) Exotic spicy notes 13) Long lingering flavors…The wine tastes decent, and is adequate Chardonnay, though the less expensive Kirkland Signature Sonoma Chardonnay tastes better for a lower price. Drink 2018-2022- 89
Owen Bargreen- This golden colored Chardonnay starts off with lighter tree fruit aromas with a touch of butter on the nose. The palate has good balance currently commanding brioche, buttered popcorn and papaya flavors. This is highly simplistic Chardonnay. The tasting description on the bottle borders absurd in my mind, noting ‘fig’ flavors here. Furthermore the description on the back of the bottle essentially fools the consumer to think that they are drinking a bottle of Kongsgaard Chardonnay — thought to be the finest expression of California Chardonnay. Aside from this wine not being particularly inspiring, I can’t understand the deceptive nature to the back of this wine label. Drink 2018-2022- 87
Scott Doleshel- I enjoyed this wine, showing a good sense of place, as this mirrors many of the quality wines from this region. There is good balance to the wine with medium bodied flavors of pineapple, mango and bright acidity. I also cannot understand how this wine is described on the back of the label, which is nowhere near how it drinks. Drink 2018-2024- 89
2016 Kirkland Signature ‘Carneros’ Pinot Noir ($9.99)
Stephen Lee- The 2016 Kirkland Signature ‘Carneros’ Pinot Noir is very light in color. Barbecue sauce on the nose connects with the lighter red fruits. On the palate there are flavors of raspberry, tar, tobacco. This Pinot Noir is a surprisingly complex wine for the price. Drink 2018-2022- 89
Owen Bargreen- The 2016 Kirkland Signature ‘Carneros’ Pinot Noir is a really good value California Pinot Noir. The nose comes off impressively with cherry cola and orange rind showing most prominently. Forward and downright delicious, juicy guava, red cherry candy, cola and cran-orange flavors come together nicely in the glass. Enjoy this in the short-term. Drink 2018-2022- 88
Scott Doleshel- Here we have a straightforward California Pinot Noir, that shows a good combination of richness and balance. Red and dark fruits dominate the palate with solid acidity. I am really impressed with the value here. Drink 2018-2024- 89
2012 Kirkland Signature Brunello di Montalcino ($21.99)
Stephen Lee- The 2012 Kirkland Signature Brunello di Montalcino is my favorite wine of this tasting. The wine was aged in oak for three years prior to bottling. Tobacco and shoe leather on the nose connect with lighter tones of baking spices. Orange peel flavor dominates the palate with a touch of rose petal. The wine finishes well, and is less astringent than I would have expected. The wines rough edges smoothed out as it was decanted for a few hours. Drink 2018-2028- 91
Owen Bargreen-This translucent colored Sangiovese starts off with blood orange, dusty terroir and sweet pipe tobacco on the nose. Forward, showing light tannins, the wine shows off red cherry, pomegranate seed, and citrus rind flavors with a touch of damp earth. This is a bit simplistic but the earthy tones nicely round things out. Drink 2018-2025- 88
Scott Doleshel- The 2012 Kirkland Signature Brunello di Montalcino is my favorite wines out of this bunch. I love the earthy terroir and dark and red fruits here that connect with the minerality. This wine is impressive. Drink 2018-2028- 91
2016 Kirkland Signature ‘Cuvee de Nalys’ Chateauneuf du Pape ($17.99)
Stephen Lee- The back of the bottle asserts that this wine is showing ‘Notes of blueberry, cherry and mineral.’ I find this CDP to fall flat (as do many CDP’s in the price range), lacking acid, and is generally uninteresting. That said I find no major faults with the wine either. Drink 2018-2024- 88
Owen Bargreen Domaine de Nalys takes its name from the original founders of the estate who owned the property in the 1700’s. The domaine was confiscated during the French Revolution, broken into smaller parcels and sold at auction. The wine needs more than a one hour decant to fully evolve. This begins with delicate aromas of red currant, red raspberry cordial, rose petal and suggestions of Provencale herbs that build in the glass. Red currant jelly, provencal herbs and wet stone with cherry candy flavors all mingle in the glass. A head-turning value, showing some bright acidity, this will continue to evolve well over the next decade. Drink 2018-2026- 90
Scott Doleshel- I can’t say I am impressed with this CDP. Red fruits and a touch of sweetness make me feel like the wine is out of balance. Drink 2018-2022- 87
2015 Kirkland Signature ‘Pauillac’ Bordeaux Red Wine ($22.99)
Stephen Lee- Coming from one of Bordeaux’s best years, this wine does not disappoint, having been aged for 9 months in French oak prior to bottling. Leather and blackberry present on the nose. Following an hour decant, this wine is ready for enjoyment. Well-balanced showing nice oaky tones and dark fruits, this young Bordeaux is ready to open today Drink 2018-2028- 90
Owen Bargreen The nose delivers a nice combination of dark and red fruits with dusty terroir, particularly damp earth. The mid-palate comes off a bit lean, with herbal and dark fruit tones. Not particularly recommended, as I can’t see this improving considerably. Drink 2018-2022- 86
Scott Doleshel- I really feel that this is an unimpressive effort as a Bordeaux. There is limited weight and acidity drives this wine. Light red and dark fruits leave me uninspired. Drink 2018-2022- 85
2016 Kirkland Signature ‘Columbia Valley’ Cabernet Sauvignon ($8.89)
Stephen Lee- Baking spices and loganberries display on the nose. The wine comes off as a touch jammy, lacking complexity on the palate. It’s not the best example of Columbia Valley Cabernet, as I would have expected more bell pepper/pyrazine character. Drink 2018-2022- 88
Owen Bargreen- This shows nice dark fruits with toasty oak on the nose combining with a touch of sagebrush. The palate is forward and slightly sweet, delivering copious dark fruits with a touch of milk chocolate and sage. This is a serious value. Drink 2018-2022- 88
Scott Doleshel- Here we have a very forward wine that shows dark fruits and limited complexity. Dark berry flavors are quite primary. Dink 2018-2022- 86