Today we share one of the outstanding producers of Walla Walla. I met with Jay Krutulis and Matt Reilly who both had successful careers before starting a winery together. This was now my second visit to Prospice and I feel like the wines are getting better and better. The wines were initially very well-structured but a bit lacking in flavor density. This has changed over the past five years as reds continued to be tension-filled but have plenty of depth and also better and better nuance. An example of this is what they are doing with fruit from the Rocks District. The wine shows plenty of stony essence and nuance without being out of balance. I tasted the latest set of wines mainly from the 2021 vintage that saw a good amount of heat, with few heat spikes.
Both Jay and Matt were impressed with the wines from 2021 despite the heat. “It was a little harder making wines with tension in 2021 and we did a lot of hunting around and that is why we didn’t do a varietal Merlot” Jay said. “But when you taste through these wines from 2021 they are a lot more balanced than you think. The acidity is there. We were able to develop an elegant tannin profile and this for me goes back to the silky tannins that for me start to build back up to the front of the palate.”
For years I have loved what they have done with their Rose program. The new 2023 Prospice Rose (OB, 92) is a beautiful wine that is very light on its feet, with good texture from the battonage given. The best wine I tasted was the outstanding 2019 Prospice ‘Quintessence Reserve’ Cabernet Sauvignon (OB, 95) which has loads of richness and great Red Mountain character. Learn more at prospicewines.com and here are my reviews of the new wines by Prospice.
2023 Prospice Rose- This 2023 Rose combines 57% Grenache with 27% Cinsault and the remainder Counoise all coming from the Lonesome Spring Vineyard. A very pale color, this was stored in stainless steel tanks as this saw considerable lees stirring. This shows bright cantaloupe tones alongside red rose petals and orange peel notes. This is fresh and lithe with a polished texture. Very crisp and bright, this is a gorgeous bottling that is highly nuanced and delicious. Drink 2024-2030- 92
2023 Prospice Grenache Blanc- This 2023 Grenache Blanc come from the Les Collines Vineyard in the foothills of the Blue Mountains. Stored in all neutral barrels this is a more linear style of GB, showing off kiwi, green papaya and orange blossom tones on the nose. The wine is very fresh and shows a smooth texture alongside gooseberry and melon tones alongside copious minerals. Drink 2024-2029- 92
2023 Prospice Viognier- The 2023 Viognier comes from the Gamache Vineyard. The wine was stored in all neutral French oak before bottling. Yellow plum, white peach and shades of Pink Lady apple all combine with honeysuckle tones on the nose. The palate is lithe and nicely textured with good underlying tension. Showing serious nerve, and good concentration, this has some good aging potential. Drink 2024-2031- 93
2021 Prospice ‘BDX’ Red Wine- The 2021 ‘BDX’ combines 64% Merlot with 28% Cabernet Sauvignon and the remainder Cabernet Franc and a touch of Petit Verdot. Stored in 39% new French oak before bottling. This is very performed with red rose petals that combine with black currants, espresso ground and damp earth. Medium-bodied with good finesse, this is already nicely defined stuff that will cellar well over the next eight to ten years. Drink 2024-2032- 93
2021 Prospice ‘Phinny Hill’ Cabernet Franc- This 2021 Cabernet Franc has just a dash of Petit Verdot added. The wine is very pure in terms of black fruit profile with black cherry and creme de violette, alongside tar and tobacco leaf notes. This is seriously good stuff. Only 120 cases made. Drink 2024-238- 94
2021 Prospice ‘Phinny Hill’ Cabernet Sauvignon- The 2021 Prospice ‘Phinny Hill’ Cabernet Sauvignon is a beautiful wine that was stored in 53% new French oak which is the highest percentage of any wine that the winemaking team has done. Very densely colored in the glass, this offers sagebrush alongside green bell pepper, dark currants and suggestions of pencil lead. The palate is neatly textured with good weight and structure. Give this another year in the bottle. Drink 2025-2040- 94
2020 Prospice ‘White Bluffs’ Cabernet Sauvignon- This comes from the Dionysus and Bacchus Vineyards including some old plantings from the 1970s. This is wonderfully herbal with fresh sage alongside milk chocolate and black currant cordial. Smooth and polished with a refined texture, this is drinking beautifully right now. Enjoy now and over the next few years. Drink 2024-2030- 93
2019 Prospice ‘Reserve Quintessence Vineyard’ Cabernet Sauvignon- This limited production bottling comes from the Quintessence Vineyard on Red Mountain. This has beautiful flavor density considering the coolness of the vintage as they had picked prior to the freeze event in October 2019. Blackberry compote, scorched earth and tar notes combine with anise and graphite on the palate. Refined and elegant, showing a seamless textural quality this is a beautiful wine that is built to age. Drink 2024-2042- 95
2021 Prospice ‘Africa’ Red Wine- The 2021 ‘Africa’ is a Rhone-inspired blend that is mainly Syrah (94%). This smells beautifully perfumed with rose petals alongside green olives, charcuterie and shades of red licorice. Fresh and lithe, with a smooth texture, this is a killer wine for the price. Drink 2024-2030- 92
2020 Prospice ‘Meravina’ Red Wine- This Cabernet based 2020 ‘Meravina’ offers sagebrush and dark chocolate shavings on the nose. This is soft and refined stuff that is drinking very well now. Drink 2024-2030- 91